Side by side
| Compared on | Shopify Basic | WooCommerce |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | US$25, about R422 | Your hosting, from about R99 |
| Fee per sale | 2% with a South African card provider | None |
| Billed in | US dollars | Rands, on local hosting |
| Hosting and security | Done for you | You arrange and maintain it |
| Updates | Automatic | WordPress, the theme and every plugin, by hand |
| Extra features | Apps, many billed monthly | Plugins, many free, paid ones billed yearly |
| Design freedom | Within a theme | Anything, with code |
| When it breaks | Shopify's support | You, your host or a developer |
Cost
Selling R20 000 a month, Shopify Basic comes to about R822: R422 for the plan and R400 as Shopify's share of your sales. At R50 000 a month it is about R1 422.
WooCommerce has no plan and takes no share. A small shop can run on South African hosting from about R99 a month. WooCommerce's own estimate for most shops is US$25 to US$350 a month for hosting, and US$29 to US$299 a year for each paid extension.
So on paper WooCommerce is cheaper at every size. What the numbers leave out is time.
Upkeep
A Shopify shop looks after itself. A WooCommerce shop is a WordPress site, and a WordPress site needs someone to update it, back it up and fix it when two plugins disagree.
If that someone is you and you enjoy it, WooCommerce is hard to beat. If it is a developer at an hourly rate, one broken checkout can cost more than a year of Shopify's fees. Be honest about which of those you are.
Payments
Both work with PayFast, Yoco, Peach Payments and Paystack. The provider's fee is the same on either one. The difference is that Shopify adds its 2% on top, and WooCommerce adds nothing.
The providers themselves are compared in payment gateway fees in South Africa.
Which one for you
Pick Shopify if
- you want to sell, not maintain a website
- you need a specific Shopify app
- you sell overseas or in a physical shop too
Pick WooCommerce if
- you already run WordPress and know your way around it
- you want full control of the design and code
- fees matter more to you than time
A third option
This part is about Storeforge, which we make.
If you want Shopify's "it just runs" without the share of sales, and WooCommerce's rand pricing without the upkeep, that is the gap Storeforge was built for: R299 a month, nothing per sale, hosted and maintained for you. It has no app store and is built for selling in South Africa only, so it does not replace either of the others for everyone.
All four options are in online shop platforms compared.
Common questions
Is WooCommerce really free?
The plugin is free. You pay for hosting, a domain, any paid extensions, and the time it takes to keep WordPress updated and backed up. WooCommerce's own estimate is US$25 to US$350 a month for hosting, though a small South African shop can start on local hosting from about R99 a month.
Which is cheaper in South Africa, Shopify or WooCommerce?
WooCommerce, on fees. Shopify Basic is about R422 a month plus 2% of your sales. WooCommerce has no monthly platform fee and takes nothing per sale. The cost of WooCommerce is upkeep: if you pay a developer by the hour, one bad month can cost more than a year of Shopify.
Which is easier to run?
Shopify. It is hosted for you, updates itself and has support you can contact. WooCommerce gives you more control, and with that comes plugin updates, security and backups.
Do both work with South African payment providers?
Yes. PayFast, Yoco, Peach Payments and Paystack all work with both. On Shopify you also pay Shopify's own 2% on those sales, on Basic. On WooCommerce you only pay the provider.
Can I move from one to the other?
Yes, in both directions. Products and photos move across cleanly. Order history and customer passwords usually don't. We do these moves if you would rather not.
Shopify, WooCommerce, Wix, Yoco, PayFast, Paystack, Peach Payments and PayGate are trademarks of their owners. ForgeLab is independent of all of them and names them only to compare. Prices change, so check each company's own page before you decide.